Chapter Roadmap
Theme: the board decides investments – but money going to an associated company needs members' special resolution and strict conditions. Directors are fiduciaries: they must disclose any interest, stay out of the decision, and related party deals must follow a board-approved policy.
Associated Companies & Undertakings [Section 2(4)]
Two or more companies / undertakings are associated if…
- a person who is the owner, partner or director of one, or holds (directly or through spouse / minor children) ≥ 20% of voting power in it, is also the owner, partner or director of the other, or holds ≥ 20% in it; or
- they are under common management or control, or one is the subsidiary of the other; or
- the undertaking is a modaraba managed by the company (modaraba – Islamic, interest-free financing set-up floated by a licensed modaraba management company).
IGNORED when testing association
- directorship by nomination of a Government Minister or a Government-owned / controlled financial institution
- directorship as an independent director
- shares owned by the National Investment Trust or a Government-owned / controlled financial institution
- shares registered in the name of a central depository not beneficially owned by it
MCQ: a directorship nominated by an ordinary (non-Government) financial institution is not excluded.
| Example | Associated? |
|---|---|
| Azam – director of ABC Ltd and DEF Ltd (Ex. 01) | YES companies |
| Azam also a partner of GHI Enterprises | YES undertakings |
| Babar – director of ABC; owns > 20% of JKL (Pvt) Ltd (Ex. 02) | YES |
| ABC holds DEF and KLM; DEF vs KLM (Ex. 03) | YES common control |
| NIT owns 25% of ABC and 30% of XYZ (Ex. 04) | NO |
| Saima – director of ABC; independent director of XYZ (Ex. 05) | NO |
| Kingfish holds 16% of Moonfish, no common director | NO – board approval enough |
Investment in Associated Companies [Section 199]
"Investment"
Includes equity, loans, advances, guarantees by whatever name called – except normal trade credit on arm's-length terms under the company's trade policy.General power
Investment decisions are made by the directors in board meetings (e.g. Kalaam Ltd buying 8% of an unconnected company).Loan agreement must include
• purpose
• period
• rate of return
• repayment schedule (principal & return)
• penalty for default / late payment
• security, if any
If return not recovered
Return must be recovered regularly per the agreement – otherwise the directors are personally liable to make the payment. An interest-free loan to an associated company (Blush Pakistan → Jade Packaging) breaches the minimum-return rule.| Scenario | Why associated → what's needed |
|---|---|
| Kalaam Ltd lends Rs. 100m to Monsoon (Pvt) Ltd (holds 25%, two common directors) | Common directorship → special resolution, agreement, minimum return, due diligence |
| Snow Storm Ltd invests Rs. 200m in Flipper (Pvt) Ltd – Ironside owns 51% and 52% | Common control → same conditions |
| Silver Topaz (18% of Jade Ltd) nominated a director; buys 10% more | Common directorship → special resolution |
| Blush Pakistan & Jade Packaging – both managed by Ivory (Pvt) Ltd | Common management → special resolution; file it in 15 days; annex to articles |
| Aramis Ltd – extra 25% loan for associated company's project | Change in amount → new special resolution (circulation if unlisted ≤ 50 members, or EGM) |
| Nakin Tyre Ltd lends Rs. 50m to Axis Rubber (Pvt) Ltd | Bashir holds 20/100 = 20% of NTL; in ARL he holds 2/50 = 4% + wife Nasira 37/50 = 74% → 78% → associated |
Investments Held in the Company's Own Name [Section 200]
Rule
All investments made by a company on its own behalf must be made and held in its own name.Exception ① Minimum members
Shares in a subsidiary may be held in a nominee's name so that its members don't fall below the statutory minimum. (ABC's 100% unlisted public subsidiary needs 3 members → 2 nominees.)Exception ② Qualification shares
Where the company can appoint a director of another company, shares up to the nominal value of that director's qualification shares may be held jointly with, or solely in the name of, the nominee. (Mr. Afzal – 10,000 shares.)Exception ③ Central depository
Securities may be placed in the name of the central depository company (as trustee) – beneficial ownership stays with the company.| Falcon Cars Ltd – shares in others' names | Justified? |
|---|---|
| Albatross (100%, unlisted public) – 1 share each with Muneer and Salman | YES keeps 3 members |
| Raven Cars (15%, listed) – 10% in Owais's name as nominated director | YES if RCL's articles require 10% qualification shares (15% > 100% ÷ 7 = 14.28% gives a board seat) |
| Coot Trackers (5%, unlisted, already 5 members) – 1 share with Qaim | NO no exception applies |
Oliver Travels: 500 shares of its wholly owned private subsidiary in employee Rahim's name (private needs 2 members) and 5,000 TTPL shares in nominee director Sami's name (qualification shares) – both justified. Non-compliance: company – fine up to Rs. 5 million; officer in default – imprisonment up to 2 years or fine up to Rs. 1 million, or both.
Register of Investments Not Held in Own Name [Section 200]
Contents
Kept at the registered office; entered forthwith – nature, value and particulars identifying the shares / securities.Inspection
Members free; others on fee fixed by the company – during business hours, at least 2 hours each day.Certified copies
Any member, on request and fee – issued within 7 days. On contravention the registrar may compel inspection / copies.Disclosure of Interest by Directors [Section 205]
Why & what
Directors are agents in a fiduciary relationship – any director concerned or interested in a contract / arrangement (entered or to be entered) must disclose the nature of his interest at a board meeting. He is also interested if a relative (spouse, children incl. step-children, parents) is interested. Disclosure does not validate a transaction prohibited by law.| Situation | When to disclose |
|---|---|
| Transaction needs board approval – interested from the start | First board meeting where it is discussed |
| Transaction needs board approval – becomes interested later | First board meeting after he becomes interested |
| Transaction does not need board approval | First meeting after it is entered into |
General notice
A director may give one general notice of his directorships / memberships in other bodies corporate or partnerships – treated as interested in any deal with them. Given at a board meeting (or he ensures it is read at the next one). Expires at the end of the financial year; renewed by a fresh notice in the last month of the year.Interested Director Must Not Participate [Section 207]
Not to take part or vote
No part in discussion or vote; not counted in quorum; any vote cast is void.Listed company: a director with a material personal interest must not be present while the matter is considered.
Majority interested
If a majority of directors are interested, the matter goes to the general meeting for approval (Quality Tiles – 4 of 7 directors are FMF partners → contract must go to GM).Officers Other Than Directors [Section 206]
Rule
Any other officer directly or indirectly interested in a proposed contract must disclose the nature and extent of the interest and obtain the board's prior approval before entering into it. (Akram – CFO of Snapper House – company renting his wife Najma's building.)Time Limits & Numbers
| Requirement | Limit | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Voting power linking associated companies | ≥ 20% | 2(4) |
| Return on loan to associated company | ≥ higher of borrowing cost / SECP rate | 199 |
| File special resolution with registrar | 15 days | 150 |
| Inspection of investments register / certified copy | 2 hours daily · 7 days | 200 |
| General notice of interest valid until | Year end (renew in last month) | 205 |
| Ratify an unapproved related party contract | 90 days | 208 |
| Listed company penalty | 3 years / ≥ Rs. 5m | 208 |
Exam Question Patterns & MCQ Quick Clues
CAF-04 – CHAPTER 9 IN 60 SECONDS
- Associated: common owner / partner / director or ≥ 20% holder · common control or subsidiary · managed modaraba · exclusions (independent, Govt nominees, NIT, CDC).
- Investment = equity, loans, advances, guarantees (not trade credit) · board decides generally.
- In associates: special resolution (nature, period, amount, terms) · written loan agreement · return ≥ borrowing cost / SECP rate · due diligence certificate · directors personally liable.
- Own name rule · exceptions: subsidiary minimum members · qualification shares · CDC · register (members free, 2 hours, copies in 7 days).
- s.205: disclose at board · relatives count · general notice till year end.
- s.207: no discussion / vote / quorum · listed: leave the room · majority interested → GM.
- s.206: other officers need prior board approval.
- s.208: related parties · board policy · majority interested → special resolution · arm's-length exempt · ratify in 90 days or voidable · listed: 3 years / ≥ Rs. 5m.
Chapter Memory Map
Test yourself on Company Law
Practice ICAP-pattern CAF-4 BLD MCQs with full explanations – Chapter 2 is free for everyone. Enrol for all chapters and the weekly test session.