Learning League Practice MCQs
Home › Revision Notes › CAF-4 BLD · Company Law
CAF-4 · BLD · COMPANY LAW (VOL II) · CHAPTER 9

Investments and Disclosure of Interest

Associated Companies & Undertakings · Investment in Associated Companies · Investments Held in the Company's Own Name · Register of Investments Not Held in Own Name · Disclosure of Interest by Directors · Interested Director Must Not Participate

Revision Notes · Premium Revision Series · Prepared by Haleema Lateef · Learning League
1

Chapter Roadmap

Investments by a Companyassociated companies · special resolution · own name · register (Sec. 1)
→
Disclosure of Interestdirectors · officers · related party transactions (Sec. 2)
→
Objective Based Q&A(Sec. 3)

Theme: the board decides investments – but money going to an associated company needs members' special resolution and strict conditions. Directors are fiduciaries: they must disclose any interest, stay out of the decision, and related party deals must follow a board-approved policy.

2

Associated Companies & Undertakings [Section 2(4)]

Two or more companies / undertakings are associated if…

  • a person who is the owner, partner or director of one, or holds (directly or through spouse / minor children) ≥ 20% of voting power in it, is also the owner, partner or director of the other, or holds ≥ 20% in it; or
  • they are under common management or control, or one is the subsidiary of the other; or
  • the undertaking is a modaraba managed by the company (modaraba – Islamic, interest-free financing set-up floated by a licensed modaraba management company).

IGNORED when testing association

  • directorship by nomination of a Government Minister or a Government-owned / controlled financial institution
  • directorship as an independent director
  • shares owned by the National Investment Trust or a Government-owned / controlled financial institution
  • shares registered in the name of a central depository not beneficially owned by it

MCQ: a directorship nominated by an ordinary (non-Government) financial institution is not excluded.

ExampleAssociated?
Azam – director of ABC Ltd and DEF Ltd (Ex. 01)YES companies
Azam also a partner of GHI EnterprisesYES undertakings
Babar – director of ABC; owns > 20% of JKL (Pvt) Ltd (Ex. 02)YES
ABC holds DEF and KLM; DEF vs KLM (Ex. 03)YES common control
NIT owns 25% of ABC and 30% of XYZ (Ex. 04)NO
Saima – director of ABC; independent director of XYZ (Ex. 05)NO
Kingfish holds 16% of Moonfish, no common directorNO – board approval enough
3

Investment in Associated Companies [Section 199]

"Investment"

Includes equity, loans, advances, guarantees by whatever name called – except normal trade credit on arm's-length terms under the company's trade policy.

General power

Investment decisions are made by the directors in board meetings (e.g. Kalaam Ltd buying 8% of an unconnected company).
Special resolutionin general meeting stating nature, period, amount and terms & conditions (any increase or change also needs one)
+
Written agreementfor loans / advances – per members' approval
+
Minimum returnnot less than the higher of investing company's borrowing cost or rate specified by SECP
+
Due diligence certificatedirectors certify borrower can repay

Loan agreement must include

• nature of loan
• purpose
• period
• rate of return
• fees or commission
• repayment schedule (principal & return)
• penalty for default / late payment
• security, if any

If return not recovered

Return must be recovered regularly per the agreement – otherwise the directors are personally liable to make the payment. An interest-free loan to an associated company (Blush Pakistan → Jade Packaging) breaches the minimum-return rule.
ScenarioWhy associated → what's needed
Kalaam Ltd lends Rs. 100m to Monsoon (Pvt) Ltd (holds 25%, two common directors)Common directorship → special resolution, agreement, minimum return, due diligence
Snow Storm Ltd invests Rs. 200m in Flipper (Pvt) Ltd – Ironside owns 51% and 52%Common control → same conditions
Silver Topaz (18% of Jade Ltd) nominated a director; buys 10% moreCommon directorship → special resolution
Blush Pakistan & Jade Packaging – both managed by Ivory (Pvt) LtdCommon management → special resolution; file it in 15 days; annex to articles
Aramis Ltd – extra 25% loan for associated company's projectChange in amount → new special resolution (circulation if unlisted ≤ 50 members, or EGM)
Nakin Tyre Ltd lends Rs. 50m to Axis Rubber (Pvt) LtdBashir holds 20/100 = 20% of NTL; in ARL he holds 2/50 = 4% + wife Nasira 37/50 = 74% → 78% → associated
4

Investments Held in the Company's Own Name [Section 200]

Rule

All investments made by a company on its own behalf must be made and held in its own name.

Exception ① Minimum members

Shares in a subsidiary may be held in a nominee's name so that its members don't fall below the statutory minimum. (ABC's 100% unlisted public subsidiary needs 3 members → 2 nominees.)

Exception ② Qualification shares

Where the company can appoint a director of another company, shares up to the nominal value of that director's qualification shares may be held jointly with, or solely in the name of, the nominee. (Mr. Afzal – 10,000 shares.)

Exception ③ Central depository

Securities may be placed in the name of the central depository company (as trustee) – beneficial ownership stays with the company.
Falcon Cars Ltd – shares in others' namesJustified?
Albatross (100%, unlisted public) – 1 share each with Muneer and SalmanYES keeps 3 members
Raven Cars (15%, listed) – 10% in Owais's name as nominated directorYES if RCL's articles require 10% qualification shares (15% > 100% ÷ 7 = 14.28% gives a board seat)
Coot Trackers (5%, unlisted, already 5 members) – 1 share with QaimNO no exception applies

Oliver Travels: 500 shares of its wholly owned private subsidiary in employee Rahim's name (private needs 2 members) and 5,000 TTPL shares in nominee director Sami's name (qualification shares) – both justified. Non-compliance: company – fine up to Rs. 5 million; officer in default – imprisonment up to 2 years or fine up to Rs. 1 million, or both.

5

Register of Investments Not Held in Own Name [Section 200]

Contents

Kept at the registered office; entered forthwith – nature, value and particulars identifying the shares / securities.

Inspection

Members free; others on fee fixed by the company – during business hours, at least 2 hours each day.

Certified copies

Any member, on request and fee – issued within 7 days. On contravention the registrar may compel inspection / copies.
6

Disclosure of Interest by Directors [Section 205]

Why & what

Directors are agents in a fiduciary relationship – any director concerned or interested in a contract / arrangement (entered or to be entered) must disclose the nature of his interest at a board meeting. He is also interested if a relative (spouse, children incl. step-children, parents) is interested. Disclosure does not validate a transaction prohibited by law.
SituationWhen to disclose
Transaction needs board approval – interested from the startFirst board meeting where it is discussed
Transaction needs board approval – becomes interested laterFirst board meeting after he becomes interested
Transaction does not need board approvalFirst meeting after it is entered into

General notice

A director may give one general notice of his directorships / memberships in other bodies corporate or partnerships – treated as interested in any deal with them. Given at a board meeting (or he ensures it is read at the next one). Expires at the end of the financial year; renewed by a fresh notice in the last month of the year.
7

Interested Director Must Not Participate [Section 207]

Not to take part or vote

No part in discussion or vote; not counted in quorum; any vote cast is void.
Listed company: a director with a material personal interest must not be present while the matter is considered.

Majority interested

If a majority of directors are interested, the matter goes to the general meeting for approval (Quality Tiles – 4 of 7 directors are FMF partners → contract must go to GM).
Exceptions: (i) director of a private company that is neither a subsidiary nor a holding company of a public company; (ii) a director who acted as surety for the company, where the resolution is about indemnifying / insuring him against loss as surety.
Hasan Ali (Faraz Ltd): negotiating with Bari Ltd whose CEO is his wife → disclose at the first board meeting where the contract is considered; then stay out of the discussion and vote.
Fida Rehman (Golden Industries, listed): contract with Carol (Pvt) Ltd on 9 Nov 2025; his father buys 12% of CPL on 7 Mar 2026 → disclose at the first board meeting after 7 Mar 2026; general notice expires at year end, renew in the last month.
8

Officers Other Than Directors [Section 206]

Rule

Any other officer directly or indirectly interested in a proposed contract must disclose the nature and extent of the interest and obtain the board's prior approval before entering into it. (Akram – CFO of Snapper House – company renting his wife Najma's building.)
11

Time Limits & Numbers

RequirementLimitSection
Voting power linking associated companies≥ 20%2(4)
Return on loan to associated company≥ higher of borrowing cost / SECP rate199
File special resolution with registrar15 days150
Inspection of investments register / certified copy2 hours daily · 7 days200
General notice of interest valid untilYear end (renew in last month)205
Ratify an unapproved related party contract90 days208
Listed company penalty3 years / ≥ Rs. 5m208
12

Exam Question Patterns & MCQ Quick Clues

"Power to make investments rests with…"
→
Directors
"Investment in associated company needs…"
→
Special resolution in general meeting
"Investment includes…"
→
Equity, loans, advances, guarantees
"Register of investments not in own name – members inspect…"
→
Free, at least 2 hours daily
"Majority directors interested in a related party deal"
→
Special resolution in general meeting
"Interested director may still take part if he is director of…"
→
Private co. – not holding / subsidiary of public
"Unapproved contract is saved if ratified within 90 days by…"
→
Either directors or shareholders
"Nominee director's shares registered in his name"
→
Only qualification shares per articles
⚠ CHAPTER 9 EXAM TRAPS
Trap: Normal trade credit on arm's-length terms is not an investment.
Trap: Independent directors, Government / Government-FI nominees, NIT and CDC holdings do not create association.
Trap: Return on a loan to an associate = higher of borrowing cost and SECP rate – interest-free loans are not allowed.
Trap: "Relative" for disclosure (s.205) = spouse, children (incl. step), parents; for related parties (s.208) = spouse, siblings, lineal ascendants & descendants.
Trap: An officer (not a director) needs the board's prior approval – not just a later update.
Trap: Arm's-length, ordinary-course transactions are outside s.208.

CAF-04 – CHAPTER 9 IN 60 SECONDS

  • Associated: common owner / partner / director or ≥ 20% holder · common control or subsidiary · managed modaraba · exclusions (independent, Govt nominees, NIT, CDC).
  • Investment = equity, loans, advances, guarantees (not trade credit) · board decides generally.
  • In associates: special resolution (nature, period, amount, terms) · written loan agreement · return ≥ borrowing cost / SECP rate · due diligence certificate · directors personally liable.
  • Own name rule · exceptions: subsidiary minimum members · qualification shares · CDC · register (members free, 2 hours, copies in 7 days).
  • s.205: disclose at board · relatives count · general notice till year end.
  • s.207: no discussion / vote / quorum · listed: leave the room · majority interested → GM.
  • s.206: other officers need prior board approval.
  • s.208: related parties · board policy · majority interested → special resolution · arm's-length exempt · ratify in 90 days or voidable · listed: 3 years / ≥ Rs. 5m.
13

Chapter Memory Map

Associated Companies20% TestExclusionsMeaning of InvestmentSpecial ResolutionLoan AgreementMinimum ReturnDue DiligenceOwn-name RuleNominee ExceptionsInvestments RegisterDirector's DisclosureGeneral NoticeNo Vote When InterestedOfficer's DisclosureRelated PartiesOffice of ProfitArm's Length90-Day Ratification

Test yourself on Company Law

Practice ICAP-pattern CAF-4 BLD MCQs with full explanations – Chapter 2 is free for everyone. Enrol for all chapters and the weekly test session.

All CAF-4 BLD Company Law (Vol II) revision notes
  1. Introduction and Types of Companies
  2. Memorandum and Articles
  3. Directors
  4. Chief Executive and Other Officers
  5. Share Capital and Commencement of Business
  6. Mortgages and Charges
  7. Meetings and Resolutions
  8. Distribution of Profits
  9. Investments and Disclosure of Interest
  10. Accounts and Annual Return