Learning League Practice MCQs
Home › Revision Notes › CAF-4 BLD · Company Law
CAF-4 · BLD · COMPANY LAW (VOL II) · CHAPTER 10

Accounts and Annual Return

Key Definitions · Books of Accounts · Annual Financial Statements · Approval & Signing · Filing with Registrar after AGM · Quarterly Financial Statements

Revision Notes · Premium Revision Series · Prepared by Haleema Lateef · Learning League
1

Chapter Roadmap

Books of Accounts(Sec. 1)
→
Financial Statementsannual · authentication · filing · quarterly (Sec. 2)
→
Group Financial Statements(Sec. 3)
→
Directors' Report(Sec. 4)
→
Annual Return(Sec. 5)

Theme: every company keeps proper books, prepares true-and-fair financial statements, has them approved, signed, audited, sent to members and filed; listed companies also report quarterly; holding companies consolidate; directors report; and every company files an annual return.

2

Key Definitions

Books and paper [Section 2(10)]

Books of account, cost accounting records, deeds, vouchers, writings, documents, minutes and registers – on paper or in electronic form.

Books of account [Section 2(11)]

Records of: (a) all money received and spent; (b) all sales and purchases of goods and services; (c) all assets and liabilities; (d) items of cost in production, processing, manufacturing or mining.

Financial year [Section 2(34)]

The period for which financial statements laid before the general meeting are made up – whether a year or not.

Financial statements [Section 2(33)]

(a) statement of financial position; (b) statement of profit or loss and OCI (not-for-profit: income & expenditure); (c) changes in equity; (d) cash flows; (e) notes incl. accounting policies; (f) comparative information; (g) others prescribed. CFO [2(15)]: individual performing a CFO's customary duties.
3

Books of Accounts [Section 220]

Requirement

Keep at the registered office books of account, other books and papers and financial statements for every year giving a true and fair view (incl. branches). Production, processing, manufacturing or mining companies also keep specified particulars of material, labour and other cost inputs.

Other place

Board may keep them elsewhere in Pakistan – notice to registrar with the full address within 7 days of the decision (SQL Plastics: factory in Peshawar).

Branch offices (in or outside Pakistan)

Proper books kept at the branch + summarised returns sent periodically to the registered office (or other place) → compliant.

Retention

Books for at least 10 financial years immediately preceding a year, with vouchers. Liquidator must keep them too. EHL (inc. 2000; decision 15 Mar 2022) may dispose of books up to FY 2011.

Inspection by DIRECTORS

Any director, during business hours; copies of information kept outside Pakistan must be produced; staff must assist. A director noticing branch discrepancies may raise it with the board and seek details.
Members have no absolute right to inspect books of account. Ejaz Alam (member, Salmon Ltd) cannot inspect books at the Multan office, and the company need not give 15 years of statements – only 10 years must be kept.
4

Annual Financial Statements [Section 223]

First FSlaid in AGM within 16 months of incorporation
→
Subsequent FSat least once each calendar year, within 120 days after year end
→
Extension ≤ 30 daysCommission (listed) / registrar (others)
→
Periodnot more than one year (except first) unless registrar permits

Audit

Audited by the company's auditor; auditor's report attached. Exempt: private company with paid-up capital not exceeding Rs. 1 million (or higher notified amount).

Dispatch – 21 days before the meeting

Audited FS + auditor's report + directors' report (+ chairman's review report if listed) to every member and person entitled to notice – by post or electronically. Copy kept at registered office for members.
Listed company: simultaneously send 3 copies by post + 1 electronically to each of the Commission, registrar and securities exchange, and post on the website.
5

Approval & Signing [Section 232]

Company / situationApproved by board and signed by
General ruleChief executive + at least one director
Listed companyCEO + at least one director + CFO
CEO not in PakistanAt least two directors (listed: plus the CFO – Raza Enterprises)
Single member companyOne director
Private company, paid-up ≤ Rs. 1 millionAlso an affidavit by the signatories that the FS were approved by the board (Aquamarine (Pvt) Ltd)
6

Filing with Registrar after AGM [Section 233]

Time limit

Listed: within 30 days of the AGM.
Others: within 15 days.

Not adopted?

Still file – annex a statement of the fact and reasons if the meeting does not adopt, defers or is adjourned.

Exempt

Private company with paid-up capital not exceeding Rs. 10 million (or higher notified). Every public unlisted company must file.
7

Quarterly Financial Statements – Listed Companies [Section 237]

Adeel Ltd (YE 30 June)Time limitDue
Q1 – 30 Sep 201930 days30 Oct 2019
Q2 / half year – 31 Dec 201960 days29 Feb 2020
Q3 – 31 Mar 202030 days30 Apr 2020
Annual – 30 June 2020120 days28 Oct 2020

Second quarter extras

Cumulative half-year figures; limited scope review by the statutory auditors (terms by ICAP, approved by SECP). Q1 and Q3 need no review.

Publish & transmit

Posted on the website; transmitted electronically to the Commission, securities exchange and registrar within the time limit. Physical copy to a member on request free. Signed like annual FS.

Extension for Q1: only if the annual FS were extended – Commission may extend Q1 filing by up to 30 days (Relax Furniture Ltd: annual extended to 27 Nov 2019; Q1 due 30 Oct 2019 also extended). ABC Ltd's Q2 to 31 Dec 2021 → due 1 March 2022.

8

Worked Practice Questions – Deadlines

Red Ltd (listed) – YE 30 Nov 2021; audit ends 28 Mar 2022

Lay annual FS – 120 days after 30 Nov 202130 Mar 2022
Dispatch 21 days before → would need to send by 8 Mar 2022 – impossible → apply to the Commission for extension—
Meeting with 30-day extension29 Apr 2022
File adopted FS with registrar – 30 days after meeting29 May 2022
Q1 (to 28 Feb 2022) – 30 days; ready only ~12 Apr → seek extension (allowed as annual FS extended)Due 30 Mar → 29 Apr 2022

Dates Ceramics Ltd (unlisted; inc. 1 Jul 2021)

• First AGM & FS within 16 months → 31 Oct 2022 (planned 22 Oct impossible after fire)
• Apply to registrar → up to 30 days → 30 Nov 2022
• First directors retire at first AGM – continue till successors elected; report any impediment to election to registrar at least 45 days before the due date
• Election meeting not delayed beyond 90 days of due date → 29 Jan 2023

Company incorporated 1 Aug 2022

First AGM planned 8 Dec 2023 is late – first FS must be laid within 16 months → by 30 Nov 2023. Audited (unless private ≤ Rs. 1m); sent 21 days before with reports.
9

Consolidated Financial Statements [Section 228]

Requirement

A holding company attaches to its own FS the consolidated FS of the group, presented as a single enterprise, complying with the relevant Schedule and notified reporting standards. Audited and reported on by the holding company's auditor; signed by the same persons who sign the holding company's FS; ss. 223, 233–236 apply to the holding company. Material subsidiary-related qualifications not covered in the holding company's FS must be disclosed.

Exception

A private company and its subsidiary where none has paid-up capital exceeding Rs. 1 million. Commission may also relax on application. Default → level 2.

Interim closing

If a subsidiary's year end precedes the holding company's by more than 90 days, it makes an interim closing on the holding company's year end. (GPL, YE 31 Dec → interim FS 1 Jul 2019 – 30 Jun 2020 for RPL; Pintail YE 31 Aug → interim closing 31 Dec 2024 for Shoveler.)

Financial years to coincide [s.229]

The holding company's board ensures its and its subsidiaries' years coincide unless good reasons against. The Commission may extend the year of either company on its application, with incidental relaxations (Oregano Ltd → FFL).
10

Holding Through Subsidiaries – Worked Practice Q (Muskmelon)

(i) Is BPL a subsidiary of DL?

EL: DL holds 30,000 ÷ 50,000 = 60% → EL is DL's subsidiary
AL: DL 35% + EL 35% = 70% → AL is DL's subsidiary
BPL – DL itself 3,800 ÷ 20,00019%
BPL – through EL 4,000 ÷ 20,00020%
BPL – through AL 10,200 ÷ 20,00051%
Controlled by DL90%

(ii) Is AL a subsidiary of CPL?

DL: CPL holds 288,000 ÷ 400,000 = 72% → subsidiary; EL is DL's subsidiary → CPL's too
AL – CPL itself 3,000 ÷ 10,00030%
AL – through DL 3,500 ÷ 10,00035%
AL – through EL 3,500 ÷ 10,00035%
Controlled by CPL100%

AL, CPL and DL – as holding companies – must prepare consolidated FS.

Nickel Motors buys 70% of Copper Tyres Ltd (public unlisted, 3 members/directors): members fall to 2 → transfer a share to an NML nominee (allowed as holding company); directors fall to 1 → nominate at least 2 natural persons (qualification shares in their names), each not a director in more than seven companies; record nominee shares in NML's register; align financial years. Kamran (son of an NML director) can be CTL's CEO though not a member.
11

Directors' Report [Sections 226 & 227]

Who prepares

The board, every year – except a private company, not a subsidiary of a public company, with paid-up capital not exceeding Rs. 3 million. Approved by the board and signed by the chief executive and a director.

Minimum contents (all)

① state of the company's affairs and a fair review of its business; ② amount recommended as dividend; ③ amount proposed for reserves.

Additional contents – public company / private subsidiary of a public company

• names of all directors during the year
• principal activities, development & performance
• principal risks and uncertainties
• changes in nature of business (company, subsidiaries, investees)
• explanation of any modification in the auditor's report
• pattern of shareholding
• name & country of a foreign holding company
• earnings per share
• reasons for loss and future prospects
• defaults in paying debts and reasons
• adequacy of internal financial controls
• material changes / commitments between year end and report date (e.g. a joint venture on 3 Sep, report dated 1 Oct)
• remuneration of each director and the CEO
• other specified information
Business review – listed company: main trends and factors affecting the future · environmental impact · CSR activities · directors' responsibility for internal financial controls · legitimate reasons for not declaring dividend despite profits, and future dividend prospects.
12

Annual Return [Section 130]

What it is

A snapshot as on a specific date of the company's CEO, directors, CFO, secretary, legal adviser, auditors, registered office, members and share capital. Form A – company with share capital; Form B – without share capital. Particulars must already be entered in the company's registers.
Date of returndate of the AGM; if no AGM held (or not concluded) – 31 December
→
Filewithin 30 days of that date
→
Extensionlisted company – registrar may extend by up to 15 days
CaseReturn datedFile by
ABC Ltd – AGM 24 Oct 202524 Oct 202523 Nov 2025
DEF Ltd – no AGM held for YE 30 June 202531 Dec 202530 Jan 2026
XYZ Ltd – AGM planned 28 Oct 2019, not held31 Dec 201930 Jan 2020
Lanvin Ltd – AGM for YE 30 June 2022 held only on 25 Jan 202331 Dec 202230 Jan 2023
Bluefish Ltd (listed) – AGM adjourned, not concluded by 31 Dec 202431 Dec 202430 Jan 2025 (+15 → 14 Feb 2025)

No change since last return

SMC and private company with paid-up ≤ Rs. 3 million → need not file anything. All other companies → inform the registrar on Form C (within the same 30 days – ABC Ltd by 23 Nov 2025).
Penalty: listed – level 2; other companies – level 1. Not holding the AGM is one contravention; not filing the return is another.
14

Time Limits & Numbers – Master Table

RequirementLimitSection
Notice to registrar – books kept elsewhere7 days220
Keep books of account and vouchers10 years220
First FS / subsequent FS16 months / 120 days223
Extension for AGM / FS≤ 30 days223
Send audited FS and reports to members21 days before223
File FS with registrar after AGM – listed / others30 / 15 days233
Quarterly FS – Q1 & Q3 / Q230 / 60 days237
Extension for Q1 (if annual extended)≤ 30 days237
Subsidiary interim closing if year end earlier by more than90 days228
Annual return filing / listed extension30 days / +15 days130
15

Exam Question Patterns & MCQ Quick Clues

"Books may be kept away from the registered office by decision of…"
→
The directors
"Who may inspect the books of account?"
→
Directors, during business hours
"Who must keep particulars of labour utilisation?"
→
Processing or mining companies (etc.)
"Directors' report is signed by…"
→
Chief executive and a director
"Who ensures holding & subsidiary years coincide?"
→
Holding company's board (not subsidiary's)
"Q3 FS of a listed company (YE 30 June) – to registrar by…"
→
30 April
"Private company with Rs. 2m capital, nothing changed"
→
Need not file annual return or Form C
"Filing difference: public unlisted vs private"
→
Public unlisted must file audited FS
⚠ CHAPTER 10 EXAM TRAPS
Trap: Members (even 10% holders) cannot inspect books of account; they inspect the financial statements kept at the registered office.
Trap: CEO abroad → two directors sign (listed: plus CFO); SMC → one director.
Trap: FS filing after AGM: listed 30 days, others 15 days – even if members did not adopt them.
Trap: Annual return date = AGM date, or 31 December if the AGM isn't held / concluded in that calendar year.
Trap: Rs. 1m / 3m / 10m thresholds belong to different reliefs – see Section 13.

CAF-04 – CHAPTER 10 IN 60 SECONDS

  • Books: registered office (or elsewhere in Pakistan – notify in 7 days) · cost records for production / mining · branches send summaries · 10 years · directors inspect.
  • Annual FS: first in 16 months · then 120 days and yearly · +30 days · audited (except private ≤ Rs. 1m) · sent 21 days before AGM · listed: SECP, registrar, PSX, website.
  • Signing: CEO + director (+ CFO listed) · two directors if CEO abroad · SMC one director · affidavit for private ≤ Rs. 1m.
  • Filing: listed 30 days · others 15 days · exempt private ≤ Rs. 10m.
  • Quarterly: listed · 30 / 60 / 30 days · half-year limited review · Q1 extension only with annual extension.
  • Group: consolidated FS · interim closing if > 90 days apart · years to coincide · level 2.
  • Directors' report: all except small private (≤ Rs. 3m) · 3 minimum items · long list for public · listed business review.
  • Annual return: AGM date / 31 Dec · 30 days (+15 listed) · Form A / B / C · SMC & private ≤ Rs. 3m skip if no change.
16

Chapter Memory Map

Books of AccountCost RecordsBranch Returns10-Year RetentionDirectors InspectFinancial Statements16 Months / 120 DaysAudit Exemption21-Day DispatchSigning RulesFiling 30 / 15 DaysQuarterly AccountsConsolidationCoinciding YearsDirectors' ReportBusiness ReviewAnnual ReturnCapital Thresholds

Test yourself on Company Law

Practice ICAP-pattern CAF-4 BLD MCQs with full explanations – Chapter 2 is free for everyone. Enrol for all chapters and the weekly test session.

All CAF-4 BLD Company Law (Vol II) revision notes
  1. Introduction and Types of Companies
  2. Memorandum and Articles
  3. Directors
  4. Chief Executive and Other Officers
  5. Share Capital and Commencement of Business
  6. Mortgages and Charges
  7. Meetings and Resolutions
  8. Distribution of Profits
  9. Investments and Disclosure of Interest
  10. Accounts and Annual Return