Learning League Practice MCQs
Home › Revision Notes › CAF-4 BLD · Company Law
CAF-4 · BLD · COMPANY LAW (VOL II) · CHAPTER 7

Meetings and Resolutions

Types of Meetings · Statutory Meeting · Statutory Report · Annual General Meeting · Extra-Ordinary General Meeting · SECP's Power to Call Meetings

Revision Notes · Premium Revision Series · Prepared by Haleema Lateef · Learning League
1

Chapter Roadmap

Company Meetingsstatutory · AGM · EGM · SECP's power (Sec. 1)
→
Service of Documents & Notices(Sec. 2)
→
Conduct of Meetingsnotice · votes · poll · proxies · quorum (Sec. 3)
→
Resolutions & Records(Sec. 4)

Theme: the kinds of meetings a company holds, the deadlines for each, how members are notified, how votes, polls and proxies work, what makes a quorum, and how resolutions and minutes are filed and kept.

2

Types of Meetings

COMPANY MEETINGS MEETINGS OF DIRECTORS MEETINGS OF MEMBERS Board meetingsall directors Committee meetingsaudit, HR, nomination, risk… General meetingsStatutory · AGM · EGM Class meetingse.g. preference holders
Note: general meetings are chaired by the chairman of the board and attended by directors – but directors vote only if they are also members.
3

Statutory Meeting [Section 131]

Who must hold it

Every public company having a share capital – once in its lifetime.
Not required if: the first AGM is held earlier; or a private company converts to public after one year of incorporation (conversion within one year → required).

When – the EARLIER of

• 180 days from the date it is entitled to commence business; or
• 9 months from incorporation.
Notice to members at least 21 days before, with a copy of the statutory report.
CompanyIncorporatedCommencement180 days9 monthsLatest date
Ex. 013 Jan 202125 Apr 202122 Oct 20212 Oct 20212 Oct 2021
Ex. 027 Jan 202122 Feb 202121 Aug 20216 Oct 202121 Aug 2021
Joint Ltd1 Feb 20181 Apr 201828 Sep 201831 Oct 201828 Sep 2018
Violet Ltd1 Aug 20211 Oct 2021*30 Mar 202230 Apr 202230 Mar 2022

*Entitlement date = registrar's acceptance of the declaration (not the date production actually started). Joint Ltd: directors' 30 Sep and 30 Oct proposals are both late – but holding the first AGM on 25 Sep 2018 removes the need. Violet Ltd cannot skip the meeting because of production problems. Greater Racket Ltd (inc. 2 Nov 2023, entitled 1 Feb 2024) → MCQ answer 29 July 2024.

4

Statutory Report – Contents & Handling

The report states

  1. total shares allotted – distinguishing those allotted other than in cash and the consideration;
  2. total cash received against shares allotted;
  3. abstract of receipts & payments up to a date within 15 days of the report – receipts (shares, debentures, others), payments, balance in hand, preliminary expenses (showing commission / discount on shares or debentures);
  4. names, addresses, occupations of directors, CEO, secretary, auditors, legal advisers and changes since incorporation;
  5. particulars of any contract to be modified needing the meeting's approval;
  6. extent to which underwriting contracts have been carried out (and reasons if not);
  7. commission / brokerage on issue of shares paid to any director, CEO, secretary, officer, or their private company.
Plus a brief account of the company's affairs since incorporation and its business plan.

Auditors' report

Accompanies the statutory report on correctness of allotment, cash received, receipts and payments.

Certified by

The CEO and at least one director (listed company: also the CFO).

Filing

Copy (with auditors' report) delivered to the registrar forthwith after sending it to members.

At the meeting

List of members (names, occupations, nationality, addresses, shares) open throughout. Members may discuss anything about formation or the report without notice – but no resolution without proper notice. May be adjourned; adjourned meeting has the same powers.
5

Annual General Meeting [Section 132]

First AGMwithin 16 months of incorporation
→
Thereafteronce in every calendar year, within 120 days after the close of the financial year
→
Extensionup to 30 days – by the Commission (listed) or registrar (others), for special reason

Every company except a single member company. Called on the order of the directors (not members).

CaseWorkingLatest date
ABC Ltd – inc. 1 Apr 2020; first AGM16 months31 July 2021
ABC Ltd – AGM for year ended 30 June 2022120 days after 30 June28 October 2022
XYZ Ltd – YE 30 Sep 2022 (first AGM held 1 Nov 2021)120 days = 28 Jan 2023, but one AGM in each calendar year31 December 2022
KTL – inc. 1 Mar 2019; directors plan first AGM 10 Aug 202016 months30 June 2020 – plan is late
Sole Fish Ltd – inc. 12 Aug 2021; YE 30 Sep16 months (no extension)12 December 2022

Place

Listed: in the town of the registered office or the nearest city; members in another city holding 10% of paid-up capital may demand video-link at least 7 days before. Others: no restriction – anywhere in Pakistan (Cod Ltd).

Notice

At least 21 days to members and all entitled persons. Listed: also sent to the Commission and published in one English and one Urdu daily newspaper with nationwide circulation.
6

Extra-Ordinary General Meeting [Section 133]

Meaning

Every general meeting other than the AGM and the statutory meeting. May be called any time; the statutory meeting is once in a lifetime.
Board callsany time for a matter needing members' approval
Requisitionmembers with ≥ 1/10 of voting power (no share capital: 1/10 of members); states objects, signed, deposited at registered office
→
Board must proceedforthwith; if not within 21 days → requisitionists may call it themselves
→
Held within 90 daysof deposit of requisition – either way

Requisitionists' expenses

Reasonable expenses are reimbursed by the company and deducted from the fees / remuneration of the defaulting directors.

Notice

21 days. Unlisted company: shorter notice if all members entitled to attend and vote agree (not for listed). Sent to members, directors and auditors.
7

SECP's Power to Call Meetings [Sections 147 & 148]

When

Default in holding the AGM or statutory meeting; or directors fail to call an EGM on requisition. The Commission may give directions on calling, holding, conducting and documents.

Effects

May direct that one member present in person or by proxy is a meeting. Deemed duly called and held. Costs paid by the company, unless recovered from an officer as directed. Default → penalty level 3.
8

Service of Documents & Notices [Sections 53–55]

On company / officers

At the registered office – against acknowledgement, post or courier, electronic means, or any specified manner. (A complaint letter to Aluminium Ltd goes this way.)

On Commission / registrar

Against acknowledgement, post or courier, electronic means, or any specified manner.

On a member

At his registered address, or if none in Pakistan, the address he supplied – same four modes.
RuleMeaningExample
Notice by postDeemed served by properly addressing, prepaying and posting; effective when it would be delivered in the ordinary course of postZahid's notice posted 2 Feb (normally 2 days) arrives 19 Feb for AGM on 27 Feb → validly served
Joint holdersNotice to the joint holder named first in the registerAzam, Babar, Chand – notice sent to Babar → Azam's claim valid; Chand's not
Death / insolvencyTo the person entitled, by name or title (representative / assignee), at the address he suppliedOfficial assignee of insolvent Sajid gets the EGM notice
9

Notice of a General Meeting [Section 134]

Contents

Place, day and hour + statement of the business. Must prominently state the right to appoint a proxy and be accompanied by a proxy form. Listed: mention the video-link option for 10% holders in another city. Special resolution: attach the draft resolution. Election: number of directors fixed and names of retiring directors.

Sent to

(i) every member (or class); (ii) every director; (iii) person entitled on death or bankruptcy of a member (if notified); (iv) the auditors.
Accidental omission or non-receipt by a member does not invalidate the meeting.

ORDINARY business (AGM only)

① consideration of financial statements and reports of board & auditors
② declaration of dividend
③ election of directors in place of those retiring
④ appointment of auditors & fixing their remuneration

SPECIAL business = everything else

e.g. obtaining a Rs. 100m financing facility, disposal of a significant segment, investment in / loan to an associated company. Attach a statement of material facts: nature and extent of every director's interest; time and place to inspect any document to be approved.
10

Chairing, Votes & Participation

① Chairman of the boardpresides
→
② Any director presentelected – if no chairman, absent after 15 minutes, or unwilling
→
③ A memberchosen by members – if no director present / willing

Votes (share capital)

Proportionate to the paid-up value of voting shares, per class entitlement; fractions ignored. Guarantee company without share capital: one vote per member.

Participation

In person, via video-link or by proxy. On a poll: personally, video-link, proxy or postal ballot. Articles cannot debar a voting member – the Act overrides (Goliath Grouper).

Single member company

All meeting / approval / election requirements are met if the decision is recorded in the minutes book and signed by the sole member / director.
11

Show of Hands vs Poll [Sections 141–145]

Show of handsPoll
WhenDefault method – unless a poll is demandedChairman's own motion, or demanded by members with ≥ 1/10 of voting power (present, video-link or proxy) – before or on declaration of the show-of-hands result
VotesOne vote per member regardless of sharesVotes per paid-up value of shares
ResultChairman's declaration (and minutes entry) is conclusive – no count neededScrutinised by chairman / nominee + representative of demanders; announced by chairman; = decision of meeting
TimingAt onceElection of chairman / adjournment → forthwith; others → within 14 days of demand
Secret ballot—Chairman's motion or demand by 1/10 of voting power

Demand may be withdrawn by those who made it. Result effective on the date the poll is actually held (Penguin Ltd – secret ballot next week is fine).

12

Proxies [Section 137]

Rules

  • Member entitled to attend and vote may appoint a proxy to attend, speak and vote.
  • Not allowed in a company without share capital unless articles permit.
  • Only one proxy per meeting – if more than one instrument is deposited, all are invalid.
  • Proxy must be a member unless articles allow a non-member.
  • Instrument in writing, signed by appointer / authorised attorney (body corporate: officer or authorised attorney). Table A form cannot be questioned.
  • Lodged at least 48 hours before the meeting – non-working days not counted; contrary article is void.
  • Proxy may demand a poll and may abstain / not use full votes.
  • Every voting member may inspect proxies during business hours.
  • Proxies deposited before an adjournment remain valid for the adjourned meeting.

48-hour rule – Jellyfish Ltd (Mon–Sat working)

AGM Monday 20 Sep 2021, 11:00 a.m.
Mon 00:00–11:00 = 11 h · Sunday not counted · Saturday = 24 h → 35 h · Friday 11:00–24:00 = 13 h → 48 h
Latest: Friday 17 Sep 2021, 11:00 a.m.

Body corporate & Government [s.138, 139]

A body corporate member (or creditor) authorises an individual by board resolution to represent it – he need not be its director or employee (JKM Ltd / Mr. Waheed). Federal (through Minister-in-Charge) or Provincial Government appoints a representative – deemed a member, may appoint a proxy.
13

Quorum of General Meeting [Section 135]

CompanyMinimum quorum (articles may fix larger)
Listed10 members present personally or via video-link, representing at least 25% of total voting power (own or proxy)
Other – with share capital2 members present personally or via video-link, representing at least 25% of voting power
Without share capitalAs provided in the articles
No quorum within ½ hour
→
Requisitioned by members→ dissolved
Called by directors→ adjourned to same day next week, same time & place
→
Adjourned meetingno quorum in ½ hour → members present (not less than two) are the quorum

Business transacted without quorum is void. Waiting only 15 minutes before adjourning (Mastermind Technologies) is wrong – wait half an hour.

14

Quorum & Voting – Worked Cases

CaseWorkingConclusion
Blue Amber Ltd (listed, 50m shares): 10 in person (10m shares) + 5 proxies (2m shares) at 9:00 for 8:30 AGMMembers ≥ 10 ✓ · 12m ÷ 50m = 24% < 25% ✗No quorum → adjourn to 13 March 2021
VX Ltd (listed): only 4 shareholders attend AGMFewer than 10Adjourn to same day next week; then ≥ 2 members
Palla Ltd (unlisted, 50m shares)2 members with 25% × 50m12.5m voting rights
Kino Ltd (unlisted, 200,000 shares) – Baber 30,000 + Fiza 60,000 attend90,000 ÷ 200,000 = 45% ≥ 25%Quorum valid
Kino Ltd – Essa's proxy lodged 8 Sep 11 AM for 10 Sep 10 AM EGMOnly 47 hoursProxy invalid
Kino Ltd – Fiza votes for, Baber against60,000 ÷ 90,000 = 67%Ordinary resolution passes; special (75%) fails
Penguin Ltd – Class A 80m × Rs. 10; Class B 15m × Rs. 20A = 80m votes; B = 15m × 2 = 30m; total 110mOnly Class A at poll → special resolution needs 60m (¾ × 80m)
ML – Class A 50m (1 vote), B 30m (2), C 20m (3); Saleem holds 50% of A25m ÷ (50+60+60 = 170m) = 14.71%> 1/10 → may requisition; change needs ¾ of affected classes B & C
15

Court May Declare a General Meeting Invalid [Section 136]

Whomembers with ≥ 10% of voting power
Where & whenpetition to the Court within 30 days of the meeting
Groundmaterial defect / omission in the notice or irregularity in proceedings that prevented members from using their rights
Orderproceedings (or part) invalid; fresh meeting
Noke Jhoke / Cartier Metal: complaining to the chairman or board achieves nothing; mere disappointment with the chairman is not enough. CML EGM 9 March 2023 → petition by 8 April 2023. Rhenium Ltd (Rs. 15m ÷ Rs. 50 = 300,000 shares) → 10% = 30,000 shares, to the Court.
Trade Ltd complaints: non-receipt of a properly sent notice – not valid · meeting began 11:25 for 11:00 (quorum within ½ hour) – valid · poll not demanded in time – complaint fails · proxy lodged late – invalid · two proxies for one member – both invalid · company represented by an authorised non-employee – valid.
16

Resolutions [Sections 140, 146 & 149]

Notice of resolution [s.140]

Notice states the general nature of each business; special resolution → draft attached. Members with ≥ 5% voting power may propose a resolution (with supporting statement) – it must reach the company with the requisition, or otherwise at least 10 days before the meeting; company circulates it forthwith. Mr. Dinshaw (13.5%) gave notice on 22 May for a 30 May AGM → too late; company not liable.

Adjourned meeting [s.146]

A resolution passed at an adjourned meeting (company, class, board or creditors) is treated as passed on the date it was actually passed. Maria Ltd: AGM 17 Aug 2020 adjourned; resolution passed 31 Aug 2020 → that date.

Resolution by circulation – members [s.149]

• Allowed for a private company or public unlisted company with not more than 50 members
• Ordinary or special – but not the ordinary business of the AGM
• Signed by ALL members entitled to notice
• Circulated with necessary papers to all members
• Agreement, once signified, cannot be revoked
• As valid as at a meeting; noted at the next meeting and made part of its minutes

Majestic Ltd (name change) and Duck Fertilizers (loan to associated company) may use circulation if unlisted / within the member limit; otherwise call an EGM (21 days, or shorter if all agree for unlisted).

17

Filing of Special Resolutions [Section 150]

Registrar

Within 15 days of passing, authenticated by a director or the secretary – filed with the registrar, not the Commission (Tripod Ltd).

Articles

A copy of every special resolution in force is embodied in or annexed to every copy of the articles issued afterwards.

Members

Copy to any member on request, on payment of the fee fixed by the company.
18

Records of Resolutions & Meetings [Sections 151 & 152]

Records [s.151]

Copies of members' resolutions passed otherwise than at meetings + minutes of all general meetings with names of participants. Authenticated by the chairman of that or the next meeting → evidence; meeting deemed duly held unless the contrary is proved. Kept at the registered office: 20 years physical, permanently electronic.

Inspection & copies [s.152]

Members inspect minutes free, during business hours – at least 2 hours each day. Certified copy: request any time after 7 days from the meeting; company supplies within 7 days of the request, for a fee. Refusal → penalty level 1; registrar may direct immediate inspection / supply (complaint goes to the registrar).
MeetingEarliest requestCopy due
RCL EGM 2 Dec 2020 (Farid asks on 5 Dec – too early)10 Dec 2020Within 7 days of the request
Trout Ltd AGM 7 Sep 2021After 7 daysRequest on 21 Sep → within 7 days
Hen (Pvt) Ltd AGM adjourned and concluded 6 Mar 202414 Mar 202421 March 2024
19

Altering Share Capital – Worked Practice Q (Crimson Ltd)

StepClass AClass B
Shares (m)Face Rs.Rs. mShares (m)Face Rs.Rs. m
Authorised – current1,2001518,0008004032,000
(i) Cancel 350m Class B—4504018,000
(ii) Consolidate 2 A → 16003018,000—
(iii) Sub-divide 1 B → 2—9002018,000
Paid up – current600159,0004004016,000
After (ii) / (iii)300309,0008002016,000

Procedure: general meeting (or circulation if unlisted with ≤ 50 members) with draft resolution and statement of material facts → special resolution → alter capital clause (if articles allow) → file with registrar within 15 days. Cancellation does not affect paid-up capital.

20

Non-cash Deal Approved at General Meetings – Brown Enterprises Ltd

Orchid Ltd's direct holding in BEL: 125m ÷ 500m25%
Through its subsidiary Teal Ltd: 130m ÷ 500m26%
Total → BEL is a subsidiary of Orchid Ltd51%

Zakir (NED of BEL and OL) swaps land for the 5th floor of BEL's mall → prior resolutions in general meetings of BEL and OL; notices give the land's and the floor's value by a registered valuer and a statement of material facts incl. Zakir's interest.

21

Time Limits & Numbers – Master Table

RequirementLimitSection
Statutory meeting – earlier of commencement / incorporation180 days / 9 months131
Notice of statutory meeting / AGM / EGM21 days131–133
First AGM after incorporation16 months132
Subsequent AGM after year end (and once each calendar year)120 days132
Extension of AGM (Commission / registrar)≤ 30 days132
Video-link demand (listed; 10% holders in a city)7 days before132
EGM requisition – voting power / board to act / meeting held1/10 · 21 days · 90 days133
Chairman absent – directors elect one after15 minutes134
Quorum wait / adjourned to½ hour · same day next week135
Court petition against meeting (10% voting power)30 days136
Lodging of proxies (working time)48 hours137
Members' resolution – voting power / notice before meeting5% · 10 days140
Poll demand / poll taken within1/10 · 14 days143–145
File special resolution with registrar15 days150
Minutes – physical / electronic20 years / permanent151
Certified minutes – request after / supplied within7 days / 7 days152
22

Exam Question Patterns & MCQ Quick Clues

"Private company must hold a statutory meeting if it converts…"
→
Within one year of incorporation
"On a show of hands every member has…"
→
One vote, irrespective of shares
"Resolution by circulation is NOT allowed for…"
→
Ordinary business of the AGM
"Circulated special resolution (45 members) is passed only if signed by…"
→
All members entitled to notice
"Chairman present but unwilling to chair the AGM"
→
Directors present elect one of them
"Special resolution for filing is authenticated by…"
→
A director or company secretary
"Notice to joint shareholders Zaid, Rohan & Khalid"
→
The one named first in the register
"Member refused inspection of minutes – remedy"
→
Complaint to the registrar
"EGM vs statutory meeting"
→
EGM any time; statutory once in a lifetime
⚠ CHAPTER 7 EXAM TRAPS
Trap: Statutory meeting date = the earlier of 180 days from entitlement to commence and 9 months from incorporation – not the date operations actually began.
Trap: AGM must satisfy both the 120-day rule and the once-per-calendar-year rule. SMCs need no AGM.
Trap: Short-notice EGM is allowed only for unlisted companies with consent of all members.
Trap: No quorum → requisitioned meeting is dissolved; directors' meeting is adjourned.
Trap: Two proxies for one meeting → both invalid, not just the second.
Trap: Board minutes: 10 years physical; general meeting minutes: 20 years physical (both permanent electronic).
Trap: Poll threshold 1/10 of voting power; members' resolution 5%; court petitions 10%.

CAF-04 – CHAPTER 7 IN 60 SECONDS

  • Statutory meeting: public company with share capital · earlier of 180 days / 9 months · report certified by CEO + director (+ CFO if listed) with auditors' report.
  • AGM: first within 16 months · then 120 days after year end and once per calendar year · +30 days extension · 21 days' notice.
  • EGM: board or 1/10 requisition · board acts in 21 days · held within 90 days · SECP may call (one member may be quorum).
  • Notices: registered address · post deemed served · first-named joint holder · to members, directors, heirs, auditors.
  • Business: 4 ordinary AGM items · everything else special (statement of material facts).
  • Voting: hands = 1 per member · poll by chairman or 1/10 · within 14 days · secret ballot possible.
  • Proxies: one per meeting · member unless articles allow · 48 working hours · may demand poll.
  • Quorum: listed 10 + 25% · others 2 + 25% · ½ hour → dissolve / adjourn · adjourned: 2 present.
  • Resolutions: 5% may propose (10 days) · circulation for unlisted ≤ 50 members · special filed in 15 days.
  • Minutes: 20 years physical / permanent · inspect free · certified copy after 7 days, within 7 days.
23

Chapter Memory Map

Types of MeetingsStatutory MeetingStatutory ReportAGM – 16 Months / 120 DaysPlace & Video-linkEGM & RequisitionSECP Calls MeetingService of NoticesOrdinary vs Special BusinessChairingNumber of VotesShow of Hands vs PollProxies – 48 HoursCorporate RepresentativeQuorumCourt – 10% / 30 DaysMembers' ResolutionsCirculationFiling – 15 DaysMinutes & Inspection

Test yourself on Company Law

Practice ICAP-pattern CAF-4 BLD MCQs with full explanations – Chapter 2 is free for everyone. Enrol for all chapters and the weekly test session.

All CAF-4 BLD Company Law (Vol II) revision notes
  1. Introduction and Types of Companies
  2. Memorandum and Articles
  3. Directors
  4. Chief Executive and Other Officers
  5. Share Capital and Commencement of Business
  6. Mortgages and Charges
  7. Meetings and Resolutions
  8. Distribution of Profits
  9. Investments and Disclosure of Interest
  10. Accounts and Annual Return