1
Chapter Roadmap
Share Capitalnature · authorised & paid up · classes · variation of rights (Sec. 1)
→
Alteration of Share Capital Clauseincrease · consolidate · sub-divide · cancel (Sec. 2)
→
Commencement of Businessprospectus · statement in lieu · conditions (Sec. 3)
→
Objective Based Q&A(Sec. 4)
Theme: what a share is, the different layers of share capital, ordinary vs preference shares, how class rights are varied and challenged, how the capital clause is altered, and when a public company may start business.
7
Challenging the Variation in Court [Section 59]
Who
Member(s) of the affected class holding at least 10% of that class, aggrieved by the variation – application may be made by one or more of them authorised in writing.Where & when
To the Court (not the registrar or Commission), within 30 days of the date of the resolution.After the order
Company files a copy of the court's order with the registrar within 15 days of receipt.Ground 1 – facts withheld
The company withheld facts in getting the resolution passed – had members known them, they would not have passed it (relevant where the applicant voted for it).Ground 2 – unfair prejudice
The variation is otherwise prejudicial / would unfairly prejudice the class (relevant where the applicant voted against it).| Scenario | Advice |
|---|---|
| Pioneer Shipping – Ahmed 9% and Faraz 10% of Class A oppose new Class B | Together (19%) – and Faraz alone (10%) – meet the 10% test → apply to Court within 30 days |
| Paradise Ltd – special resolution on 20 Aug 20X3 varies Class B rights | Aggrieved Class B holders with ≥ 10% of Class B → apply within 30 days of 20 Aug |
| Sapphire Ltd – Class A voting rights increased by 50%; Faiza (Class B) objects | If she holds ≥ 10% of Class B (alone or with others authorising her in writing) → Court within 30 days |
| Candid Oils – Class B votes cut from 2 to 1 per share | Class B holders with 10% or more of Class B → apply to the Court |
If the Court cancels the resolution (Cadmium Limited)
Company can no longer implement the variation · must reverse actions taken under it · file the court order with the registrar within 15 days · re-file the articles in their previous form · every copy of the articles issued afterwards must follow the court's decision.9
Private → Raising Money from the Public
Practice Q – Swordfish (Private) Limited (authorised & paid-up Rs. 400m; wants Rs. 200m from the public)
Memorandum:
• remove "(Private)" from the name
• if raising by shares – increase authorised capital by at least Rs. 200m
• remove "(Private)" from the name
• if raising by shares – increase authorised capital by at least Rs. 200m
Articles:
• remove "(Private)" from the name
• remove restriction on transfer of shares
• remove the limit on number of members
• remove the prohibition on inviting the public to subscribe
• remove "(Private)" from the name
• remove restriction on transfer of shares
• remove the limit on number of members
• remove the prohibition on inviting the public to subscribe
10
Prospectus vs Statement in Lieu of Prospectus
Prospectus
Formal document issued by a public company inviting the general public to subscribe for its shares or debentures – details of the company, financial position, risks and investment opportunity, to help investors decide.Statement in lieu of prospectus
Filed with the registrar when a public company does not issue a prospectus – similar but lesser details; used when shares / debentures are not offered to the general public.| Circumstance | Document |
|---|---|
| Inviting the general public, or company listed on stock exchange | Prospectus |
| Not inviting the public to subscribe | Statement in lieu of prospectus |
| Issued a prospectus but could not obtain listing | Repay all money received on the prospectus and file a statement in lieu of prospectus |
Filing before issue [Section 57]: no prospectus shall be issued unless, on or before its publication, a copy signed by every person named as a director or proposed director is filed with the registrar – else the company and every party to its issue, publication or circulation is liable to penalty.
11
Listing Process Before Allotment (Example 08)
Issue prospectusfix payment date; apply to exchange for listing
→
Public deposits moneyin banks as required
→
Wait for listingresolve exchange's queries
→
Listeduse applicants' money; allot shares
Refusedrepay money forthwith – cannot commence business until repaid
12
Commencement of Business [Section 19]
A public company shall not start operations or exercise any borrowing powers unless:
(a) Minimum subscription
Shares for cash allotted for not less than the minimum subscription.(b) Directors paid in full
Every director has paid in full, in cash, on each share taken or contracted to be taken by him (not every member).(c) Nothing to repay
No money is or may become liable to be repaid to applicants for shares offered for public subscription.(d) Declaration
A duly verified declaration by the chief executive or a director and the secretary that (a)–(c) are complied with is filed with the registrar.(e) Statement in lieu
If no prospectus inviting the public was issued – a statement in lieu of prospectus is filed with the registrar.Conclusive evidence
Registrar, after enquiries, accepts and registers the documents → conclusive evidence the company may start operations and borrow.Minimum subscription
Amount fixed by the MoA / AoA on which directors may proceed to allotment; if none fixed – the whole share capital issued for cash (e.g. funds needed for building, machinery and working capital).Section 19 does not apply to
• a private company• a company converted from private to public
• a company limited by guarantee without share capital
13
Consequences of Non-Compliance [Section 20]
Penalty: every officer or other person responsible for starting business or borrowing in contravention is liable to the prescribed penalty (without prejudice to other liabilities).
Contracts: any contract made before the company is entitled to commence business is provisional only – not binding until that date, and becomes binding on that date.
Blue Whale Ltd (incorporated 3 Sep 2021; will never approach the public; starts business next month) → must file a statement in lieu of prospectus.
14
Time Limits & Numbers
| Requirement | Limit | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Majority of affected class to vary its rights | 3/4 | 38 |
| File altered articles with registrar | 30 days | 38 |
| Minimum holding of affected class to apply to Court | 10% | 59 |
| Apply to Court against variation (from date of resolution) | 30 days | 59 |
| File Court's order with registrar (from receipt) | 15 days | 59 |
| File special resolution & altered MoA after capital alteration | 15 days | 85 |
15
Exam Question Patterns & MCQ Quick Clues
"Share capital is introduced by the company's…"
→
Members
"Issued share capital, compared with authorised capital…"
→
May be less – never more
"Authorised capital can be increased only with approval of…"
→
Shareholders (special resolution)
"Ordinary shares are also called…"
→
Equity shares
"Preference share – prior right to…"
→
Repayment of capital on winding up
"Prima facie evidence of title to a listed company's shares"
→
Certificates in book-entry form
"Nominal share capital means…"
→
Maximum capital authorised by the MoA
"Shares are movable property transferable as provided by…"
→
Articles of association
"A prospectus must be signed by…"
→
Every named director / proposed director
"Before trading, a public company must have…"
→
Incorporation + commencement of business
"A prospectus is needed when a company…"
→
Raises capital from the general public
Trap: Only directors (not all members) must have paid in full in cash before commencement of business.
Trap: Variation challenges go to the Court – not the Commission or registrar – by holders of 10% or more of the affected class (not of total capital).
Trap: Capital clause alteration → file within 15 days; alteration of articles → 30 days. Don't swap them.
Trap: If no minimum subscription is fixed, it is the whole capital issued for cash – not the authorised capital or the amount received.
Trap: Sub-division / consolidation does not change total capital or proportional rights.
Trap: Pre-commencement contracts are provisional, not void – they bind the company once it is entitled to commence business.
16
Chapter Decision Tree
QUESTION GIVEN → ① About a share? movable property · fully paid · distinctive number · certificate (physical / book-entry) → ② About capital? authorised (MoA maximum) ≥ issued / paid up · publish both equally → ③ New class / changed rights? MoA & AoA must allow → special resolution + 3/4 of affected class → file AoA in 30 days → challenge: 10% of class · Court · 30 days · file order in 15 days → ④ Change in capital clause? articles must authorise · special resolution · increase / consolidate / sub-divide / cancel unissued · file in 15 days → ⑤ Public company starting business? minimum subscription · directors paid · nothing to refund · declaration · prospectus or statement in lieu → registrar's acceptance = conclusive
CAF-04 – CHAPTER 5 IN 60 SECONDS
- Share = share in share capital · movable property · transferable per articles · fully paid · distinctive number.
- Authorised = MoA maximum · issued / paid up ≤ authorised · publish both with equal prominence.
- Nominal = par / face value · market = trading price.
- Ordinary vs preference: votes · residual vs fixed prior dividend · surplus vs prior return of capital only.
- Variation: special resolution + 3/4 of class · Court challenge by 10% of class within 30 days · facts withheld or unfair prejudice · order filed in 15 days.
- s.85: increase · consolidate · sub-divide · cancel unissued – if articles allow · special resolution · file in 15 days · rights stay proportional.
- Prospectus for public offers (signed by all directors) · statement in lieu otherwise.
- s.19: minimum subscription · directors paid · nothing refundable · declaration · statement in lieu → conclusive registration · exempt: private, converted, guarantee without share capital.
- s.20: penalty on responsible officers · earlier contracts provisional until entitled.
17
Chapter Memory Map
Nature of SharesIssue → Subscribe → AllotAuthorised CapitalPaid-up CapitalEqual PublicationFully Paid OnlyNominal vs MarketKinds & ClassesOrdinary vs PreferenceVariation of RightsCourt – 10% / 30 DaysCapital Clause (s.85)Sub-division ExampleProspectusStatement in LieuCommencement ConditionsMinimum SubscriptionProvisional Contracts
Test yourself on Company Law
Practice ICAP-pattern CAF-4 BLD MCQs with full explanations – Chapter 2 is free for everyone. Enrol for all chapters and the weekly test session.
All CAF-4 BLD Company Law (Vol II) revision notes