Learning League Practice MCQs
Home › Revision Notes › CAF-4 BLD · Company Law
CAF-4 · BLD · COMPANY LAW (VOL II) · CHAPTER 8

Distribution of Profits

Who Does What? · Profits that CANNOT be Distributed · Payment of Dividend · Manner of Payment · Book Closure · Directors Cannot Withhold Declared Dividend

Revision Notes · Premium Revision Series · Prepared by Haleema Lateef · Learning League
1

Chapter Roadmap

Declaration of Dividendimplied power · restrictions (Sec. 1)
→
Payment of Dividendform · period · manner · book closure · no withholding (Sec. 2)
→
Objective Based Q&A(Sec. 3)

Theme: dividends are payments to members out of distributable profits. The board recommends, members declare (never more than recommended), and the chief executive must pay within a strict deadline – with only limited, approved exceptions.

2

Who Does What?

Boardrecommends / proposes final dividend; declares interim dividend
→
Members in AGMapprove final dividend by ordinary resolution – may accept, reduce or reject, never increase
→
Chief executiveresponsible for paying within 10 working days

Implied power to declare dividend

Unless the memorandum / articles restrict it (e.g. an association not for profit prohibits dividends), every company has an implied power to use its profits to pay dividends.

Not more than recommended [Section 240]

The company in general meeting may declare dividends, but no dividend shall exceed the amount recommended by the board. The CEO does not "declare" dividend – he informs members of the board's recommendation.
3

Profits that CANNOT be Distributed [Section 240]

① Profit on sale of capital assets

No dividend out of profit on sale / disposal of immovable property, assets of a capital nature or any undertaking – unless both:
  • the company's business (wholly or partly) is buying and selling such property / assets; and
  • the profit is first set off against losses on sale of such property / assets.

② Unrealised gain on investment property

A fair-value increase credited to profit and loss on an investment property not yet sold is unrealised – it cannot be used for dividend.

Ex. 03: bought Rs. 100m, fair value Rs. 120m → Rs. 20m gain not distributable.

CaseWorkingDistributable?
Manufacturer sells factory building – profit Rs. 20m (Ex. 01)Not in property businessNO
Property developer – profit on land Rs. 10m, loss on another property Rs. 3m (Ex. 02)10 − 3Rs. 7m (subject to other law)
Pear Ltd – b/f profit Rs. 100m; business profit Rs. 300m; land gain Multan Rs. 150m; land loss Jhelum Rs. (350m)Land gain set off against land loss → net loss (200m); 100 + 300 − 200Rs. 200m maximum
4

Payment of Dividend [Sections 241 & 242; Distribution of Dividends Regulations, 2017]

Form

Only out of profits – in cash or in kind. Dividend in kind may only be shares of a listed company held by the distributing company.

To whom

Only to registered shareholders or to their order, within the period and manner specified – Companies (Distribution of Dividends) Regulations, 2017.
DividendDeemed declared onPay within (by CEO)
Final dividendDate of the general meeting (AGM) approving it10 working days from the date of declaration
(working day = any day banks are open)
Interim – with book closureDate book closure starts (for entitlement)
Interim – without book closureDate the board approves it
Listed company: book closure for interim dividend must start within 15 days of the board's approval. Ashanti Ltd: board declares on 18 Sep 2025, book closure 28 Sep – 3 Oct → deemed declared 28 Sep 2025 → pay within 10 working days of 28 Sep. Peach Ltd: no book closure → deemed declared on the date of board approval (9 Sep 2022).
5

Manner of Payment

Listed company

Cash dividend only through electronic mode, directly into the bank account designated by the shareholder.

Other companies [Reg. 4]

Obtain a dividend mandate when a person becomes a shareholder – one of: (i) direct bank transfer; (ii) dividend warrant (works like a crossed cheque, credited to the member's account); (iii) crossed cheque. Mandate may be changed any time by written request.

Paying agent

A company may appoint a paying agent – a bank or entity (incl. share registrar, central depository) with SBP approval – to pay cash dividend directly into bank accounts. Banks may act as their own paying agent.
6

Book Closure [Section 125]

Purpose

A period in which the company does not register share (or debenture) transfers – to fix the cut-off for who receives a notice of meeting or dividend (or interest). Persons holding shares at the start of book closure are treated as the members.

Notice

at least 7 days before

Maximum

30 days in total in each year

Extension

Commission may extend by 15 days

Penalty

Default → level 2

Applies to the register of members (or any class) and of debenture-holders. Listed: notice advertised in one English and one Urdu daily newspaper with wide circulation. Notice served like other notices (registered address, first-named joint holder, legal representative).

Worked Practice Q – Bluefish Ltd (listed)

Closed 10 days (Jan) + 7 days (Apr) + 8 days (Jul) = 25 days → only 5 days left of 30. Jaleel's planned 8 days: either cut it to 5 days, or apply to the Commission for an extension of at least 3 days.
7

Directors Cannot Withhold Declared Dividend [Section 243]

Rule

Once declared, it is unlawful for directors to withhold or defer payment; the chief executive is responsible for paying within the specified period.

Consequences of late payment – CEO

  • Imprisonment up to 2 years and fine up to Rs. 5 million.
  • On conviction, ceases to be CEO from that day.
  • Ineligible for 5 years to be CEO or director of that or any other company.

Akram Khan, convicted in January 2020 for late dividends, cannot be a director of Sardine Ltd until five years have passed.

No offence – if SECP permits withholding / deferral

On the company's application within 45 days of declaration (after hearing the shareholder), where:
  • payment is barred by operation of law;
  • a shareholder's directions cannot be complied with;
  • there is a dispute over the right to receive it;
  • it is lawfully adjusted against a sum due from the shareholder;
  • failure was not due to the company's default.
Lawful withholding (no SECP approval needed): where the member has not provided complete information or documents specified by the Commission.
Practice Q – Dinar Ltd (listed): 100% final dividend recommended; huge losses after the AGM notice. (i) Reduce to 25% → allowed – members may reduce in the AGM. (ii) Defer 75% for six months → not allowed – once declared, payment cannot be deferred beyond the specified period.
8

Time Limits & Numbers

RequirementLimitSection / Reg.
Pay cash dividend from date of declaration10 working daysReg. 3
Listed – start book closure after board approves interim dividend15 daysReg. 3
Notice before book closure7 days125
Book closure in a year / SECP extension30 days / +15 days125
Apply to SECP to withhold / defer45 days of declaration243
CEO's punishment for late payment2 years · Rs. 5m · 5-year bar243
9

Exam Question Patterns & MCQ Quick Clues

"Final cash dividend must be paid within…"
→
10 working days
"Members may ___ the dividend proposed by directors"
→
Accept, reduce or reject
"Members can never…"
→
Increase the proposed dividend
"Interim dividend is proposed and paid by…"
→
The directors
"Resolution to approve final dividend"
→
Ordinary resolution in the AGM
"Who is responsible for default in paying dividend?"
→
Chief executive
"Registers a listed company may close on 7 days' notice"
→
Members and debenture-holders
"Dividend warrants are credited into the account of…"
→
A member
"Primary purpose of paying dividends"
→
Reward shareholders; steady income
⚠ CHAPTER 8 EXAM TRAPS
Trap: Deadline is 10 working days – not 30 days, not calendar days.
Trap: Interim dividend with book closure is deemed declared on the first day of book closure – not the board meeting date.
Trap: Profit on selling a factory is distributable only by a company that deals in such property, and only after setting off losses.
Trap: Dividend in kind = only listed company shares held by the company.
Trap: SECP approval to withhold must be sought within 45 days; withholding for incomplete member documents needs no approval.
Trap: Fine is up to Rs. 5 million (not minimum, not Rs. 50 million); the 5-year bar covers any company.

CAF-04 – CHAPTER 8 IN 60 SECONDS

  • Dividend = payment to members out of distributable profits · implied power unless barred (not-for-profit).
  • Board recommends · members declare (ordinary resolution) · never above the recommendation.
  • Not distributable: capital profits (unless property-dealing business, after setting off losses) · unrealised investment-property gains.
  • Form: cash or listed shares in kind · only to registered holders.
  • Deemed declared: final – AGM date · interim – start of book closure / board approval.
  • Pay in 10 working days · listed: electronic only · others: mandate (bank / warrant / crossed cheque) · paying agent.
  • Book closure: 7 days' notice · 30 days a year (+15 by SECP) · listed: English & Urdu papers · level 2 penalty.
  • No withholding: CEO – 2 years + Rs. 5m + 5-year bar · exceptions with SECP approval (45 days) · incomplete documents.
10

Chapter Memory Map

Implied PowerBoard RecommendsMembers DeclareCapital ProfitsUnrealised GainsCash or KindRegistered HoldersDeemed Declaration10 Working DaysMandate & Paying AgentBook ClosureNo WithholdingCEO PenaltySECP Permission – 45 Days

Test yourself on Company Law

Practice ICAP-pattern CAF-4 BLD MCQs with full explanations – Chapter 2 is free for everyone. Enrol for all chapters and the weekly test session.

All CAF-4 BLD Company Law (Vol II) revision notes
  1. Introduction and Types of Companies
  2. Memorandum and Articles
  3. Directors
  4. Chief Executive and Other Officers
  5. Share Capital and Commencement of Business
  6. Mortgages and Charges
  7. Meetings and Resolutions
  8. Distribution of Profits
  9. Investments and Disclosure of Interest
  10. Accounts and Annual Return